Speechwriter Andrei Cherny rightly criticizes our political leaders for their plans to memoralize the September 11 terrorist attacks with words from the past rather than their own new thoughts about that day's meaning. He writes:
In a moment still crying out for context and guidance, our democratically elected officials have decided to turn to the ideas and words of the past. Instead of offering their own thoughts that day, New York Gov. George Pataki will recite Lincoln's Gettysburg Address, New Jersey Gov. James McGreevey will read from the Declaration of Independence, and New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg will recount Franklin Roosevelt's Four Freedoms. It would appear they have decided that they cannot find words equal to the occasion. Fearing a miss if they swing for the fences, they have decided to bunt.This failure, however, is but part of a series of larger national missteps. Cherny gets to this point later in his commentary:
Yet today, with al Qaeda intact, Osama bin Laden's whereabouts unknown and little required of us at home save witnessing the bizarre spectacle of old ladies being patted down at airports, some wonder whether America is ready to meet that challenge.America has largely moved on to another subject. Instead of a "dead or alive" bin Laden, the focus now is on "regime change" in Iraq. Instead of rebuilding Afghanistan, that country may be slowly returning to instability.
September 11 presented a test. For a few months, it appeared that the United States was willing to meet it. Our collective failure to confront it will make the next challenge--and be it another terrorist attack, an economic crash, or an environmental adversity there will be another--all the more difficult to solve.
By choosing merely to read history speeches, our political leaders are missing a crucial opportunity.
September 11's memorials should seek to pay tribute to those lost. They should also prepare us for the present and future challenges our nation will inevitably face. We should not settle for high school speech recitals.
